Let me start this off by saying that I consider myself as included in my argument. I know that I don't do anything close to the amount of work that is required to achieve anything more than serendipitous excellence in coaching. Please do not assume when reading this that as I point my finger at 'you', I am unaware of the four pointing back at me. I am aware that I am included.
As for interesting things - actually, there are at least two things, possibly more. The first is that, by and large, people in this country don't seem to want to do the things necessary to become seriously competitive at this sport. Most people (I can hear the cry of a thousand string-vested muscle shirts being torn in a Hogan-esque outrage) - don't want to get up crazy early every day, lift weights, watch film, or even practice at least five days a week. And the thing is, because it's the majority that seem to this pathological aversion the discipline of Becoming Great (and yes, I do include myself in the Mediocre Majority), they actually get away with it.
They don't have to work hard to compete because their competition is just as institutionally lazy, inept or both. By genetic disposition and an endemic geographical disparity of resources, most people languish in the misty twilight between (very) local notoriety and national obscurity. Those who DO excel, do so often in spite of the support systems they have at their disposal, and their achievements are often difficult to evaluate objectively due to the overall paucity of real competition in the British amateur game. That unfortunate situation creates a real challenge for those players and coaches who have true and quantifiable talent: they tend to congregate around well-established successful programs, and they tend to have to leave the UK to develop their talents to a truly elite standard. There have been previous few who have actually been able to make the transition between 'great UK player' to 'great player', and most of them are only British by birthright - often they have spent more of their developmental years in the US than at home.
The other thing I find interesting is that many of those same people who do not recognize or choose to ignore what it takes to become truly great at this sport are the same people who are the most self-congratulatory when their efforts, however minor, result in some success, however small. I have never known - in the US or in the UK - a group of participants of a minority sport that was quicker or more vocal to celebrate transitory or coincidental success than the British American football community as a whole. Facebook is swarming about this club or that, claiming to be champions of this or that. Twitter chirps constantly with boastful proclamations about a team's dominance. If Social Media is to be believed, there seems to be no limit to the pain and suffering that every team could inflict on every other. Which I find odd, and unique (in my experience) to the UK gridiron. You don't see it in British basketball, baseball, lacrosse, ultimate freaking frisbee or mother-fucking quidditch (there is an International Quidditch League, I shit you not. 300 teams, 1500 registered players and a truly international World Cup).
The reality is that coaches and players involved with the consistently best programs, the ones that truly understand what it takes to be objectively competitive; they are the ones you never hear from. Leaders and athletes - not simply participants - working at the most elite levels that the sport can offer in the UK are too busy doing the hard work to spend any real time tweeting about it. John Wooden reminds us that “Talent is God given. Be humble. Fame is man-given. Be grateful. Conceit is self-given. Be careful.”
I wish more American football coaches and players in the UK were humble, grateful and careful. Until we reconsider what it truly means to excel, we cannot truly appreciate the magnitude of our achievements (or lack thereof). It simply should not enough to be 'good for the UK'; we need to seriously think about growing the fish AND the pond. And, in the meantime, mostly keeping our mouths shut while we get to work.
The reality is that coaches and players involved with the consistently best programs, the ones that truly understand what it takes to be objectively competitive; they are the ones you never hear from. Leaders and athletes - not simply participants - working at the most elite levels that the sport can offer in the UK are too busy doing the hard work to spend any real time tweeting about it. John Wooden reminds us that “Talent is God given. Be humble. Fame is man-given. Be grateful. Conceit is self-given. Be careful.”
I wish more American football coaches and players in the UK were humble, grateful and careful. Until we reconsider what it truly means to excel, we cannot truly appreciate the magnitude of our achievements (or lack thereof). It simply should not enough to be 'good for the UK'; we need to seriously think about growing the fish AND the pond. And, in the meantime, mostly keeping our mouths shut while we get to work.
Depends what your ambition is - many people play Sunday league 'soccer' because they fancy a game, will quite happily jokingly boast of their dominance or otherwise and some may be genuinely talented, but its not their focus.
ReplyDeleteInteresting read...I've been looking at your tweets for a while and it seems to me as if there is a real problem with attitude in the sport in the UK. It also seems that many people are quite sensitive, and overreact, instead of being mature and letting their playing speak for itself. Especially when it comes to social media. My experience from other sports (most notably kickboxing) couldn't be more different. This may be for several reasons...I think it is quite difficult (unless you get to the pro levels where your trainer shelters you) to have a large ego in kickboxing...because you will always take a beating in the training ring, be it a lucky punch that knocks you down from an inferior fighter or a proper beating from someone who is better. You are always one punch or kick away, from being beaten. Taking those beatings gives you the other side so that you wouldn't want to be glorifying yourself when you know how bad it is on the receiving end. Another point is perhaps the different philosophies in coaching. Respect is quite high on the list of priorities when you are a martial arts coach. For example I have never heard of someone at a martial arts tournament shouting 'break his fucking arm.' Whereas these types of statements seem quite commonplace in uk american football, from both players and coaches. Anyway when I was on the GB kickboxing squad our motto was 'Humble in victory gracious in defeat' we would do well to remember that from time to time. Just my rambling thoughts and opinions!
ReplyDeleteThis, I think, is the root of the argument. If 'we' (the UK AF community) consider ourselves 'Sunday League', then let's act like it, on and off the pitch. If, on the other hand, we want to be taken seriously, then let's put the work in. We can't train and play like Sunday League, and then talk like the pros. I've got love for both - but let's be honest about the context of our achievements.
ReplyDeleteGreat stuff, Owen... and exactly what I'm talking about: context, humility, and perspective. We need more of all three in UKAF.
ReplyDelete